Star Trek has an up and down history pinch video games moreso than astir storied franchises. It’s uncommon for a singular crippled to properly seizure Star Trek arsenic an acquisition when, astatine its best, Star Trek debate, diplomacy, and technological investigation don’t rather statement up pinch gaming hallmarks. But nan escapade crippled genre is 1 wherever Trek has succeeded successful nan past—and for nan astir part, Star Trek: Resurgence adds to that history... pinch immoderate important caveats.
Playing Raffi Throughout Star Trek: Picard
Out this week, Star Trek: Resurgence is simply a narrative-driven, choice-based escapade crippled successful nan vein of Telltale Games’ episodic gaming series, specified arsenic The Walking Dead, Batman, Guardians of nan Galaxy, and much (developer Dramatic Labs was founded by respective erstwhile Telltale staffers aft nan workplace first efficaciously shuttered successful 2018; nan revived workplace is presently moving connected a crippled based connected The Expanse).
Whereas accepted escapade games thin heavy connected puzzles, these games are driven by subordinate prime done multi-pronged speech scenes, allowing nan subordinate to style nan way of nan narrative—a cleanable fresh for a bid for illustration Star Trek. Unlike nan oeuvre of past Telltale games, however, what sets Resurgence isolated is that it is simply a singular, 12-ish hr story, alternatively than being surgery down into episodic seasons of crippled slices. The emotion it creates is little for illustration watching an interactive section of Star Trek, and much for illustration a choose-your-own-adventure caller coming to life.
Resurgence is group successful 2380—a twelvemonth aft nan events of Star Trek: Nemesis—and follows nan unit of nan U.S.S. Resolute, a subject alloy rocked by a caller mishap that resulted successful nan nonaccomplishment of 20 of its crew, including its first officer. When caller XO Commander Jara Rydek is brought aboard, nan Resolute is tasked pinch participating successful negotiated negotiations betwixt 2 alien species, nan Alydians and nan Hotari, complete a mining world—only to observe nan root of nan conflict has dire, far-reaching implications for nan full galaxy.
Where Resurgence stands retired from anterior escapade games of its ilk, and wherever it plays to Star Trek’s strengths nan most, is successful dividing nan player’s position betwixt 2 superior characters: nan aforementioned Commander Rydek, a Kobliad serviceman thrust into nan authorities of not conscionable a caller bid but a elder unit splintered complete nan nonaccomplishment of 1 of their own, and Petty Officer Carter Diaz, an engineering crewperson trying to navigate life successful nan lowest of nan little decks connected a Federation starship pinch his champion friend, a Trill named Nili Edsilar. By making nan assemblage viewpoint screen specified a wide scope of Star Trek’s bid structure, Resurgence deftly manages to research life aboard a starship from aggregate communicative and mechanical angles.
If Jara’s sections of nan communicative are driven astir establishing herself arsenic a elder serviceman and nan authorities of diplomacy, from bid of nan span to unit meetings, Carter’s leans a small much connected nan applicable broadside of nan escapade crippled genre, problem-solving and puzzling to get his occupation done successful environments wherever his rank intends he’s not often nan go-to for big, splashy Star Trek action. Even erstwhile things spell sideways and nan full Resolute unit is thrust into an epically staked ngo to prevention nan galaxy, this disagreement successful position remains throughout, capturing nan wide Star Trek experience.
This is conscionable 1 of nan galore ways Resurgence revels successful capturing nan vibe of Star Trek—and much specifically nan vibes of his heyday successful nan precocious ‘80s and nan ‘90s, nan peaks of The Next Generation, Deep Space Nine, and Voyager defining a modern era of nan franchise beyond nan original series’ retro aesthetic. Resurgence shows its emotion of Star Trek not successful cameos and references (although their are a fewer notable characters who make appearances, including Ambassador Spock and Titan skipper Will Riker), but successful aping classical communicative elements and structures from those shows, weaving a mostly original return done nods and connections to anterior stories. Like Star Trek itself, nan action is mostly sparing, pinch nan astir hostility and conflict coming from really your characters navigate reliable bid decisions aliases debate—and moreover erstwhile things do travel to blows and conflict becomes violent, Resurgence much often than not eschews nonstop combat to alternatively attraction connected nan decisions its characters are forced to make successful those moments, alternatively than really bully they are astatine firing a phaser.
This is amplified moreover further by nan truth that Resurgence focuses connected a wholly original unit of characters. The decisions you make, from nan mundane to nan life-threatening, each consciousness for illustration they transportation a weight of uncertainty, arsenic nary characteristic is needfully guaranteed to make it retired of nan communicative successful 1 piece. You’re watching your narration to these characters turn successful real-time arsenic you determine who to put religion successful and who to support astatine arms’ length, aliases successful really you style Rydek and Diaz themselves grappling pinch nan morals of Starfleet coming up against nan desperation of their progressively hazardous mission. Resurgence is still mostly a communicative of Starfleet heroes redeeming nan day, but location is simply a level of hostility moving passim that astir Star Trek stories can’t rather seizure erstwhile you cognize nan unit you’re pursuing is going to beryllium mostly good by nan extremity of nan tale.
All of this communicative interest, however, often comes into conflict pinch nan different truth of Resurgence: it’s simply not a very nosy crippled to play. The moments you are fixed power of Jara and Carter are defined by awkward controls, clunky animation, and an erratic graphical consistency wherever characteristic models look awesome but nan environments they’re successful decidedly do not (it’s worthy stating that Resurgence will tally you $40, nether nan emblematic value of a awesome AAA crippled but still capable that it feels very unsmooth astir nan edges for that cost).
Although moments of nonstop action are uncommon successful Resurgence’s attraction connected speech choices, that’s not to opportunity they’re absent entirely. But you find yourself thankful that phaser shootouts are fewer and acold betwixt because they’re nan astir frustrating sequences of nan crippled to play; weightless action and swimmy controls are matched by frustrating neglect states that often consciousness for illustration they’re asking acold excessively overmuch of what Resurgence tin mechanically handle. This is further impacted by nan elemental truth that, for an escapade game, there’s very small existent adventuring to do. Resurgence’s determination to thin heavy connected cinematic speech choices for its interactions intends there’s small successful nan measurement of absorbing puzzles aliases devices to interact pinch nan world astir you. There’s 1 measurement to do astir things, and it’s not astir figuring that retired arsenic overmuch arsenic it is shepherding you from 1 speech series to nan next.
That linearity besides adds to Resurgence’s halfway weakness: it’s linear to nan constituent of frustration. Awkward moments wherever you’re asked to return power of your characteristic to clunkily navigate a corridor—only for a cutscene to instantly return over—make you consciousness relieved that for nan adjacent fewer minutes, nan crippled mightiness only inquire you to make a fewer speech choices alternatively of much straight play it. The single-minded thrust of nan crippled besides intends there’s small downtime betwixt awesome communicative thumps for you to casually research your surroundings, aliases get to cognize your crewmates better. Every relationship is successful nan sanction of driving nan main communicative arc forward, pinch constricted opportunities for reflection and exploration. By nan extremity of Resurgence’s 12-hour trek, that makes you consciousness for illustration a batch of those large communicative choices you’re being asked to power are mostly impactful connected nan contiguous pursuing scenes alternatively than nan larger story, taking nan wound retired of nan weight and hostility nan communicative leans connected arsenic 1 of its greater strengths.
Not rather arsenic awesome but still frustrating is that astatine slightest connected PC pinch Resurgence’s press-build, nan crippled is arsenic clunky successful its bugginess. While it’s thing terrible capable to origin a nonaccomplishment of progress, Resurgence connected PC was a symptom to navigate pinch menus not functioning right, definite menus not recognizing a gamepad (which moreover connected PC, is nan recommended power option), and, bizarrely enough, nan crippled locking up each clip I tried to adjacent it aft a session. Although gameplay is mostly spared from these issues, location are still immoderate persistent bugs while playing, successful nan shape of speech subtitles either not correctly displaying or, sometimes, showing incomplete aliases wholly different lines to what was being said—a symptom constituent from some an accessibility standpoint and a communicative standpoint, wherever respective modified subtitles provided nan subordinate pinch contextual accusation that wasn’t really said successful nan scene, making it difficult to show what mattered.
Ultimately, really consenting you are to grapple pinch nan awkward gameplay of Star Trek: Resurgence will dangle connected really overmuch you really want a new, original Star Trek story, successful a clip erstwhile there’s much Star Trek disposable successful various formats than arguably since its giddy heights successful nan ‘90s. Resurgence will very overmuch springiness you a coagulated Trek communicative populated pinch compelling characters and absorbing leads that possibly comes closest to making you consciousness for illustration you’re taking portion successful a classical Star Trek narrative—certainly much than galore different games person attempted successful decades. But that occurrence is often successful spite of itself, a not-quite gem successful nan very-much unsmooth of its clumsy, awkward mechanics.
Star Trek: Resurgence launches tomorrow, May 23, connected PC (exclusively done nan Epic Games Store), PlayStations 4 and 5, and nan Xbox Series X, S, and Xbox One.
Want much io9 news? Check retired erstwhile to expect nan latest Marvel, Star Wars, and Star Trek releases, what’s adjacent for nan DC Universe connected movie and TV, and everything you request to cognize astir nan early of Doctor Who.